Skip to main content

The Bell Jar

 The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath published in 1963 follows the story of Esther Greenwood and her journey through dealing with mental health at a time where it wasn't widely accepted. I think the most notable relationship she describes in the book is with Dr Nolan. Right away we can tell that Esther trusts and opens up to her. She is different than Dr Gordan because not only is she more open and understanding, but she is someone Esther can connect with as a woman at the time. As we continue to read, it seems as though Dr Nolan truly wants Esther to get better and actually cares about her. At one point Esther even compares her to her mother. 

One of the most notable things about Dr Nolan is her approach to electric shock therapy. She tells Esther that they didn't do it right and that if she had to do it, it would be done correctly. This immediately puts her at ease. Along with the idea that she would get a warning about it beforehand. However as we see later on, the warning comes a bit too late, even so Dr Nolan is able to calm her down and she still has trust. After the shock therapy according to Esther it does seem to work as Dr Nolan promised and we see the title of the book resurface. She describes it as the Bell Jar being lifted so she could finally breathe again. 

Comments

  1. NateMarch 10, 2023 at 3:23 PM

    I think what made Dr. Nolans treatment successful was that level of trust she was able to build with Esther. Like you said, they were able to connect much better than Dr. Gordon. Even though we didn't know any details how Esthers first shock therapy was preformed vs the second, I think the trust Esther had with Dr. Nolan helped significantly with it being successful.

    ReplyDelete
  2. TaehanMarch 11, 2023 at 12:48 PM

    Dr Nolan's unprecedented level trust that she generate with Esther really sets her apart from not only the other doctors in the book but from other characters. I think the shock therapy example that you chose is a great example of that! I also think of the birth control treatments that she prescribed as another example. I think Dr Nolan's ability to help Esther on a personal level and not think of her as another sick patient is what makes Esther trust her so much.

    ReplyDelete
  3. AnnieMarch 16, 2023 at 9:27 AM

    I agree, I think that Dr. Nolan does a good job with establishing a solid level of trust with Esther. Yous also mentioned some good points of how this was established, such as Dr. Nolan being some to whom Esther can talk about her terrible shock treatment and protect her from it. This was probably especially reassuring to Esther because all the other professionals thought that the terrible shock treatment was an effective treatment, and her mother seemed to not grasp the reality of Esthers illness. Thus, Esther was given someone to whom should confide in and reassure her that she was not crazy for hating that terrible experience. Great post!!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sag Harbor

This is going to be one of my more informal blog posts as I prepare to graduate and reflect on my time at Uni. I want to connect a lesson I've learned to Benji's ideology of "the other boy," based off the prompt we received earlier this quarter.  I think that Benji tries to separate himself so much from the younger version of himself because he's reminded of the time that him and his brother were neglected. I also think that some part of him might feel like a failure because he was trying so hard at the time to protect him and his brother from going shooting in the first place. But then his brother found a way around it and that'a how the whole mess started. All resulting in Benji getting hurt. This is an interesting aspect to explore but I really want to focus on why he tries so hard and yet fails to separate himself. I think the reason why Benji can't truly separate himself from the younger version of him is because he quite literally still has a part of...
6 comments
Read more

The Sun Also Rises: Brett and Jake

     The Sun Also Rises takes us on the journey of Brett’s adventures and life- particularly her love life. Perhaps out of all the men Brett has been with, Jake is the most notable, her relationship with him is different than those of the other men. The other’s seem to be mere hookups, other than her fiance which she doesn’t even seem to have that much of an emotional attachment to. From the first scene Brett and Jake are introduced together, we can clearly tell something is up. The taxi cab scene tells us a lot about both Jake and Brett as people but also their relationship to each other. For example, we are able to pick up on the fact that Brett is one of the only people that knows about Jake’s injury because of how they met in the war. Not only this but the scene unveils that Brett and Jake had a past that didn’t work out, and it seems as though it won’t work out in the future. The two of them want to be together but know it won’t work because it didn’t in the past....
2 comments
Read more

Invisible Man: puppet on a string

Throughout Invisible Man,  Ellison hides many metaphors that relate to the narrators life. From the reoccurring theme of running to the coin bank at Marry's, but one particularly interesting one was the doll that pops up before the climax of the book. He stumbles upon Clifton (who he doesn't notice till later) advertising and selling racist puppet dolls. Like everyone else, the narrator finds himself sucked into the doll fascinated with how it moves, he doesn't even realize Clifton is the one selling the dolls nor does he get upset that they're racist dolls. The police eventually come and everyone runs away and the narrator grabs a doll off the ground later putting it into his brief case (another reoccurring metaphor). Upon picking it up he finally realizes how the doll was able to move, it had tiny black strings which Clifton were using to move it in such a way.  This scene essentially creates a puppet on a string metaphor. In many ways, the Narrator is the puppet on t...
11 comments
Read more